James Allen Review – Are They The Best Engagement Rings?


Written by Emily


James Allen is one of the jewelry retail stores that have completely revolutionized how people purchase jewelry, especially engagement rings. Having established a majorly online business store, they have found innovative ways to meet the needs of customers looking for jewelry. Built by four creative minds, this company has grown to become one of the leading diamond engagement ring retail stores across the globe.

For a customer looking for a new approach in purchasing a ring or any other form of jewelry, this platform makes it really easy with the 360° HD photographs available on their website. They also have a magnification option where you can zoom into the items they offer to see even the smallest of details.

James Allen is renowned for its extensive collection of fine jewelry, including stunning engagement rings, and other exquisite pieces. Whether you’re searching for the perfect James Allen ring or exploring their selection of lab-created diamonds, their comprehensive range of jewelry options is sure to impress. To assist you in making an informed decision, we have compiled detailed James Allen reviews that cover various aspects of their offerings, ensuring you have all the information you need before making your purchase.

Discover the beauty and craftsmanship of James Allen rings and explore their exceptional collection of fine jewelry.

History of James Allen

James Allen began in 2006, when four creative individuals came together to build what is now JamesAllen.com. These four people included Michele Sigler, James Schultz, Oded Edelman, and Dean Lederman. Soon enough, this brand became the biggest online diamond and bridal jewelry shop that was owned privately. All these people made very significant contributions to creating the online store that we know today.

James happened to have some experience in online retail and was an early adopter of the Internet. Looking for an engagement ring for his soon-to-be wife, he found one from an online auction and purchased it. After enquiring what the ring cost, he found out that he had bought the high-quality ring for half the price of its value. He joined hands with Oded Edelman, whose family was popular for their knowledge of the diamond business. Oded was an innovator who wanted to merge what he knew with the way business is done today, which is online.

Michele, the wife to James who received the lovely engagement ring also joined in, bringing her expertise in retail and customer service to help run the business. The fourth member of this creative group was Dean, a diamantaire who had years of experience in the international manufacture and distribution of diamonds. He added to the financial and operational management of the business.

What makes James Allen stand out?

James Allen definitely stands out from the other jewelry retailers. As per their website, they are the only retailer today that has presented their 200,000+ certified conflict-free diamonds, rings, and ring settings in 360° HD that can be magnified. This means that they offer customers a detailed view of what they have to offer, making them one of the first options for people looking to purchase jewelry. Not only do they have high-quality gems, they also have 24/7 customer service and hundreds of styles that can be customized, making them a go-to store for many customers worldwide.

Another thing that stands out about James Allen is that they have the largest assortment of loose diamond that you can find online. They also have a wide range of settings that you can choose from, which you can also customize to suit your preferences. One of the most unique things I found about this store in doing my James Allen review is that they have a real-time diamond inspection. This means that you can enjoy this first-of-its-kind interactive service where experts share a screen with you and take you through some of the attributes of the diamonds you like. You get to review everything, from the grading certificate to the diamond specs which assures you that you will get something authentic.

James Allen Refund Policies and Customer Service

James Allen has 24/7 customer support for their customers. They offer a lifetime manufacturer warranty and a price match guarantee. Some of their services include rhodium plating, free re-polishing for cleanings, prong tightening, and free engraving services. One of the things that stands out about James Allen is its hassle-free return policy. They let you return an item within 30 days if you are not completely satisfied with the purchase as long as it is in its original unworn condition.

This return is a full refund or exchange that is done with no questions asked. The free return shipping option is only applicable to people in Canada and the United States, with a limit of three returns for each individual. Their website clearly outlines the steps that you can take, should you need to return your order. Read through the terms and conditions of the return policy so that you can understand which returns are accepted.

James Allen Vs Blue Nile

For most people, shopping for jewelry takes time especially if you want to get something that is perfect. It is time consuming trying to find something unique. This is why people often prefer to start their search with some of the well-known jewelry retail brands. When doing your search, some of the stores that you will come across are James Allen and Blue Nile. In this James Allen review, we will also have a look at the similarities and differences between these two stores.

The first thing we look at are the two websites. These two sites are engaging and showcase the different items they have available. James Allen however has an upper hand with their 360° HD photographs. These images give you a super clear magnified view of each item. This is important for someone looking for an engagement ring and they want to confirm even the tiniest details.

When it comes to the inventory and quality of the products, Blue Nile has more jewelry types and colored gemstones than James Allen. James Allen is however on top when it comes to engagement rings, both in terms of diversity and selection of loose diamonds. They also have a more diverse category of setting in comparison to Blue Nile. Their diamond curating standards are also higher than those of Blue Nile. This is because they take their efforts a step or two ahead.

In terms of pricing, James Allen has higher prices in comparison to Blue Nile. There are some similarities that exist between the two retail stores. This is when it comes to the 24/7 customer service availability, lifetime manufacturer warranty, and price match guarantees. One perk from James Allen that Blue Nile doesn’t have is the posh packaging. This tends to be quite significant when you’re down on one knee.

Our favorite engagement rings from James Allen

James Allen has such a broad range of jewelry items available on their online store. Some of these items include high-quality engagement rings as seen from our James Allen review. This store is a trusted retailer that has sold James Allen engagement rings to a large number of people. They have delivered successfully to different parts of the world. Here are some of our favorite engagement rings from James Allen that we think you would also love.


Does James Allen sell real diamonds?

When most people ask whether James Allen sells real diamonds, they are mostly asking because of how affordable their prices seem to be. James Allen does sell real diamonds. The reason why their prices seem far more affordable is because they are a purely online brand. This means that they do not incur the rent costs of having physical stores.

Is James Allen owned by Jared?

James Allen and Jared are some of the most popular retail jewelry stores that exist today. James Allen and Jared happen to be owned by the same parent company, which is Signet. They are however separate entities that operate independently. A significant difference between them is that while James Allen is dominantly online, Jared has quite a number of brick-and-mortar stores.

Is James Allen a reputable jeweler?

James Allen is one of the most reputable jewelers that you will find online. Their products have exceptional quality at reasonable prices and their customer service is also top-notch. They have grown so fast because of the fact that they offer authentic items which means they can be trusted.

This lovely diamond engagement ring has a pavé split shank and a stunning halo in pave setting. There are 88 round diamonds on this ring that have an average total carat weight of 0.78. The ring is crafted in 14K Yellow Gold and has width of 3.2 mm. The center stone can be a gemstone or diamond of your choice. Read more...
This elegant engagement ring has a tapered design and a channel-set that has eight round shaped diamonds. The 8 round diamonds have an average total carat weight of 0.30. The ring is crafted in 18K Yellow Gold and has a width of 3.9 mm. You can pair it with a matching band. Read more...
This modern rope style engagement ring is perfect for the contemporary woman. It has two woven diamond bands that accent center stone of your choice. This setting is beautiful and unique and showcases style and a sense of fashion. The ring has 50 round diamonds with an average total carat of 0.40. Read more...
This lovely engagement ring has a graduated diamond halo that gives it a dramatic and stylish feel. The ring has 26 round diamonds that have an average total carat weight of 0.50. The ring is crafted in 14K Rose Gold and is 1.9 mm wide. You can also get the perfect wedding band to match this ring. Read more...
This stunning diamond engagement ring has French pave set diamonds and vivid blue sapphires that frame the center diamond stone. There are 22 round blue sapphires and 18 round diamonds on this exceptionally beautiful ring, crafted in 14K Yellow Gold. Read more...
This Lovely ring has an onyx center stone that makes a bold statement. The onyx is surrounded by diamonds in 18K yellow gold metal. The black oval onyx has a total carat of 24.00 and 52 surrounding diamonds with a total carat weight of 0.30. Read more...
This lovely east-west ruby ring has accent diamonds that make it look absolutely stunning. The ring is fashioned in 14K Yellow Gold and has two round diamonds that have an average total carat of 0.02. The oval ruby has a carat of 0.60. Read more...
This stunning engagement ring has a cross over design that is absolutely unique. There is a row of pave diamonds that is weaved beautifully under the stone at the center. The ring is fashioned in 14K Rose Gold and has an average total diamond carat weight of 0.45. Read more...
This lovely ring has three rows of diamonds in a pave setting. The diamonds rise at the center into a cathedral shank to make the stone at the center the point of focus. Set in 14K Rose Gold, the ring has 68 round diamonds for an average total weight of 0.61 carats. Read more...
This stunning cushion shaped diamond ring features a round brilliant center stone for a lovely result. It has 38 diamonds for an average total carat of 0.31. The ring is also available as a traditional halo using diamonds of your choice and is crafted in 14K White Gold. Read more...